Katholieke Vereniging voor Oecumene

Athanasius & Willibrord

“Just do it?! Recognition and Reception in Ecumenical Relations” - Perspectief 2016-34

This issue of Perspectief presents five contributions to the August 2016 Academic Consultation of the Societas Oecumenica, and one paper that was written afterwards, but that fits to the theme. The stimulating core question of the conference was: “Just do it?! Recognition and Reception in Ecumenical Relations”. The papers vary from analyzing the terms to exploring practical implications for local ecumenical encounters. This issue was composed by Fokke Wouda, member of the editorial board of Perspectief and participant in the consultation.

Prof. dr. Veronika Hoffmann writes in German about recognition (Anerkennung). With her systematic analysis she proposes a theological understanding of the term. She situates our recognition of each other in ecumenical relations significantly in the framework of our being recognized by God.

Prof. dr. Gabriel Monet criticizes the fact that the processes that are regarded as significant (and as such are given implications for recognition and reception), take predominantly place at the level of church leadership and on a cognitive level. He makes an appeal for a “de-cognition of recognition.”

Dr. Petre Maican argues that the Orthodox church has an inner necessity for ecumenical dialogue. Opposing the idea that the Orthodox participation in the ecumenical movement solely consists of proclaiming the truth of the Gospel and patristic tradition, Maican advocates the conviction that the Orthodox understanding of the faith can be genuinely enriched and deepened by its dialogue partners. But how open are the Orthodox churches to acknowledging other Christian communities and their theological contribution?

Viorel Coman MA explores ecumenical strategies for fruitful dialogue. He compares Romanian theologian Dumitru Stăniloae’s concept of ‘open sobornicity’ with British scholar Paul Murray’s ‘receptive ecumenism’. In doing so, Coman seeks the balance between the roles of teacher and student, which churches have in the ecumenical dialogue.

Dr. Jelle Creemers introduces the challenging perspective of the Free Churches on recognition and reception. Because of their ecclesiological presuppositions, which are so different from the standpoints of the traditional churches, their involvement adds a new and demanding dynamic to the ecumenical process.

Giulia Casadei MA and Fokke Wouda MA work on PhD projects about Eucharistic sharing in ecumenical relations; a pressing, yet controversial topic in Roman Catholic ecumenical engagement. As they both encounter questions concerning the terminology of this field, they decided on writing an article together, in which they search for a suitable term to describe the phenomenon that they study. Their paper was only written after the consultation, but since it fits to the theme of the consultation “Just do it?!”, it is included in this issue.

De geloofservaringen die wij meemaken, individueel en in onze gemeenschappen, lijken in deze tijd soms het

TST Utrecht
On Monday afternoon 3 April we celebrate the appearance of Eduardo Echeverria's new book Divine Election:

Ferme van Frandeux
Beleef Pasen! Waar kun je Pasen beter beleven dan in het bekende oecumenische klooster van Chevetogne? Pasen 'aan den lijve' ondervinden kan ook met dans. Oud-missiesecretaris van het

Universiteit Utrecht
Wil je meer weten over oud-katholieke theologie? Ook in 2017 is er een zomercursus “oud-katholieke

Universiteit Utrecht
Can Catholics and Protestants find a common voice? In a secular society, conflict among churches is a poor

Laatste lezersreacties:

  • Pastor Paul Rens pr zei Meer
    De 18e maart was een geweldige dag op Mariëkroon. Alles was op en top verzorgd. Nu heb ik ervzring... 30 minuten geleden
  • Mario van der Grient zei Meer
    Super goed verslag. Het was een heel mooie dag. Volgende keer de vertaling van Duits naar Nederlands... 22 uur geleden
  • Thea Tinga zei Meer
    Ook ik heb genoten van een geweldige oecumensiche dag waarin ik mij met velen verbonden voelde.... 1 dag geleden.
  • Wim v Dijk zei Meer
    Mooi verslag
    Dank 5 dagen geleden



Deze website wordt mede mogelijk gemaakt door een
bijdrage van de Commissie Projecten in Nederland (PIN)
van de Nederlandse Religieuzen (KNR).




Katholieke Vereniging voor Oecumene
Emmaplein 19D 5211 VZ 's-Hertogenbosch
T:  073-7370026   M: 
KvK 51477351
IBAN-nummer:  NL97 INGB 0000 8019 19
IBAN-nummer:  NL73 INGB 0001 0876 28